• Alex Niko

  about 4 years ago

  Oh Okay, I finally figured out why on earth none of the brushes would work/show - you have to have unit scale set to 1 M! Please remove that silly dependency

  Update: I changed my review from 3 to 5 stars. The developer updated the product and now it matches my expectations.

• Greshame Carr

  about 4 years ago

  A money back policy would be good.
  It all looks great on the videos, but these are all on virtually pristine models which you could retopologise with a plane and shrinkwrap.
  Regarding Beta 3 version.
  1 : constantly crashes blender - I've tried it with every version of 2.3 I have.
  2: throws exceptions every 5 - 10 minutes
  3: the UI interface is so non responsive you'll think your computer has hung.
  4:The help screen can take up to 2 minutes to load, if at all.
  5: The help screen is modal so you can't have it open whilst working.
  6: SELECTION SELECTION SELECTION. For the love of god please sort out the selection process. I would estimate 10 - 20 attempts for every successfull selection of an edge or vertex. Some vertex are simply not selectable. You can click a vertex and a vertex two polygons away is selected. And it's so slooooooowww.
  7: Changing type of tool in the main menu does not work. You click the tool you want, and that goes grey, then flashes once and then stays that way whilst the tool you are currently using remains the selected tool. But to make this particularly annoying is that it only does it 2 - 3 times out of 10, so you think you,ve changed tool and are clicking away madly to select something before realising you still have the last tool selected.

• Piotr

  over 4 years ago

  From my own experience, this addon is only useful for low to medium count poly models and I don't recommend it for any professional work on high poly models. With any more detailed model Retopoflow will start to lag so much it would take up to 2-3 seconds to see any change on retopo mesh you are working on (for example a loop you wanted to add appears after that time). The UI is inexcusable slow to the point it also takes 2 seconds or more for it to react; the same issue applies to change values in UI settings.
  It seems the developers are unable to fix the issue considering this version of the plugin has been in beta for several or more months.

  However, if you work on low poly models only, the tool has everything it needs to do retopology with a wide variety of tools. I use it despite the issue I mentioned earlier because I haven't seen a better option.

  Have a nice day.

• tristram2k

  over 4 years ago

  Retopflow is one of the best retopology tools out there for Blender. You should get it if you sculpt in 3D or import models from other sources. It always seems to be in beta, however. I wish they would put more time into polishing it up and adding intended feature - especially because it is a bit pricey for an addon when you compare it to other powerful Blender addons (like HardOps and BoxCutter, which are constantly updated and improved for a lot less money - I know they are not the same category of addon, but the amount of development put into them at the price should be consider by the Retopoflow folks as a model). Don't overprice your stuff.

• hyunwoo kim

  over 4 years ago

  this is really great.

• J. G.

  over 4 years ago

  I've used retopoflow for probably 20 or 30 hours in the past month or so. It's the first retopology package I've used, so my comments are based solely on my experience with retopoflow; I have no idea how it compares to any other package. I *am* glad I bought this package, but it's also a bit frustrating at times because it feels like it's right on the edge of greatness, but doesn't quite make it over the line...

  Specific comments:
  - The support is pretty durned good. I originally suffered from the "can't rotate model (and other problems)" bug, and they worked with me to figure out what the issue was and how to fix it, so I could even *use* the tool, even though I very much seemed to be in the minority of users with that bug.
  - If you have to interact with the retopoflow interface directly (e.g. to change a setting), the UI is incredibly, unbelievably, spectacularly slow. It's hard to overstate *just* how slow it is. It is also sometimes unresponsive to things like tool changes. It's maddening, and I really hope it gets fixed soon!
  - The performance when actually doing retopology is usually okay, though it does sometimes get pretty slow for no apparent reason (and frequently, faster again for no apparent reason)
  - Startup time is relatively slow, which wouldn't be a big deal if I didn't need to drop out of retopoflow so often (see below)
  - It'd be really nice if there were a 'select this segment' by clicking on one end, and ctrl-clicking on the other end of an edge
  - Please please give us circle-select or the like
  - retopoflow really needs a reasonable way to select verts that are occluded by the source mesh. Working on the retopo mesh outside of retopoflow is almost guaranteed to leave some verts hidden 'under the surface', where all sorts of camera maneuvering is needed to be able to select them just to get them back on the surface
  - I find myself needing to drop back to the main blender interface to accomplish various tasks. Some of these may or may not be reasonable to expect retopoflow to do, but some of those things are:
  * set flow/set edge flow, to spread verts/edges more evenly after moving things around (this is probably my #1 most desired feature)
  * drag verts/edges while restricting the movement to one or two specific axes (useful when trying to lay out an area and be precise)
  * hide geometry (of both the input mesh and the output mesh) to be able to work properly in really tight spaces
  * to be able to add faces using the normal extrude+scale paradigm

  Overall, the tool is definitely useful, but to me it feels like it suffers from "take an interface with nothing and add features" (and leave out a bunch of things the user already had in normal blender), when it seems like it would be far more beneficial to leave us the original blender interface, and build the tool on top of that. It's really frustrating to be using a tool that's supposed to help, but have it hide other useful tools in the process...

• Jay

  over 4 years ago

  I have to say my experience with Retopoflow has been great on one side but on another not so much. Great Tools for retopology love the patch tool and strokes tools some of my favorites in retopoflow. Making hardsuface retopo easy. Though it suffers from a couple of things that mainly take away from this promising tool. One of them being its a addon that basically is a program within a program and not a part of blender itself which takes away certain things like scale, rotate and other tools such as loop tools which would be very helpful. Thus once inside of retopoflow you can not access them while your in that mode thus making you jump back and forth which hinders the workflow. I Also noticed a bit of interface lag that happens when clicking on the tools just using the interface not so much if you use the shortcuts on the keyboard.. Another problem i see is that once the mesh starts to somewhat get a bit dense the viewport starts suffering and performance starts to take a hit . Retopoflow has a lot of potential and the tools are wonderful but these problems need to be addressed for sure. I would love to see retopoflow be integrated into the N panel with its tools possibly in its own header in blender with the possible use a low level language in association with python instead of the whole program written in python this would be a great and would increase performance boost thus making this one of the best retopo tool in the biz. I hope that can come to exist. cheers

• Tom

  over 4 years ago

  New to retopo but I like how simple this made the process. Using 3.0 I found it a little slow at points but generally worked fine for me. Think i would have liked some more fill options. Also found my end result had some gaps where the polys didnt connect. Would be great to have some sort of highlight feature for the edges of the mesh to identify if something didnt snap together correct.

• lkt

  over 4 years ago

  bug bug bug

• 

  Orange Turbine

  over 4 years ago

  Hi, if you find a bug please let us know what it is! That way we can fix it. The new release of 3.0 beta 2 fixes all known crashes and several slowdowns.
• SPAC5R

  over 4 years ago

  Awesome tool! It really speeds up the process of retopologizing your mesh with a lot of helpful fine tuned tools.

  Don't expect this to do it all for you though (unfortunately). You still have to go in there and do it. And you should also know a thing or two about the retopology workflow. If you're ready to watch some tutorials and willing to learn, you'll be rewarded with a tool that awards with little successes.

  I found the tools to be very intuitive and easy to manipulate once I got the hang of it. Recommended!

• Displaying ratings 91-100 of 177 in total

Purchase this item to leave a review!